June Cleaver’s ratings: Language R; Nudity PG; Sexual Content R; Violence ; Substance Abuse R; Magic & the Occult PG; GLBT Content G; Adult Themes PG-13 (drug use and abuse, including death by overdose); overall rating R.
Liz's comments: Jordan Sonnenblick moves firmly into the realm of YA with this novel, with its Woodstock-based themes of "make love, not war", along with plenty of questionable language, people running off into the woods to have off-page sex, and an older brother's death by overdose. For those expecting a follow-up to "After Ever After" and the other books in that sort-of series, you're in for some unexpected moments. You could really tell that Jordan Sonnenblick was a fan of Woodstock and all the musicians there. The book even makes you want to go look up Jimi Hendrix's "Star-Spangled Banner" solo on Youtube...but the problem is that readers who are expecting a certain kind of book from this author will find themselves feeling somewhat betrayed. I found the book depressing in spite of the ray-of-hope bit at the end, and thought it was really better suited for a high-school audience, notwithstanding the 7-up rating from SLJ.
No comments:
Post a Comment