Friday, January 16, 2015
THE GREAT GREENE HEIST, by Varian Johnson
The story: Jackson Greene is a (supposedly) reformed con man--busted for the Mid-Day PDA, and still on the outs with former crush Gaby De La Cruz because of it. But when he hears that rich-kid Keith Sinclair is planning to bribe the principal into letting him steal the Student Council election from Gaby, Jackson knows he has to step in. Just one last con, and it's all for the greater good. Honest.
June Cleaver's ratings: Language PG; violence G; Sexual content G; nudity G; substance abuse PG; magic & the occult G; substance abuse PG; adult themes G; overall rating PG.
Liz's comments: I liked this one a lot! And Johnson certainly made a point of including someone from every demographic sub-group. Attaboy.
Wednesday, January 7, 2015
Belzhar by Meg Wolitzer
After all the hype, this was more than a slight disappointment. I had to ask myself, “If there hadn’t been so
much press about it, would I have been disappointed?” I am not sure, but I will say that there is a
big reveal that is akin to the whole “it was all a dream” plot line from the
original Dallas series, for those of you old enough to remember it. Definitely anti-climactic and gimmicky in my
opinion. Here are the basics, without
giving away too much (or is it too late?):
Jam (possibly the most ridiculous character name ever) has been sent to
a special school for emotionally disturbed teens. Internet, cell phones, etc. are not allowed except during designated
times. Students actually use a payphone
to call home. How quaint. All the students at the school are there
because of some personal or family tragedy with which they are having
difficulty dealing. Jam is selected to
participate in an elite English class, the members of which receive special
journals to use during the semester.
When the students write in the journals, they are transported (it seems
just mentally) back to a time before their tragedy. They decide to call the place they go
Belzhar, after The Bell Jar by Sylvia
Plath, which is the major work they are reading for the semester. The students in the special course become
close during their semester and each in turn is able to share his or her
tragedy and in some cases learn to get past it.
Jam, however, does not share what has happened to her, and it is with
good reason, as the reader will find out.
This reader became more than a little annoyed at her reticence and the
reason for it.
The other thing I find objectionable about this book is the
heavy-handedness of the lesson. There is
a part near the end, where the reader is treated to a fairly long didactic passage
about the value of literature. Ahem, but
the value of literature is in being able to teach with a good story and
engaging characters, not a diatribe. Overall, this is a mediocre offering,
which is probably slightly better than the average YA book. Not exactly the award-winning masterpiece I
was expecting. Is it just me, or is the
bar getting lower all the time?
June’s Rating:
Language—R; Nudity—PG; Sexual Content—PG13; GLBT Content—PG 13; Violence—PG;
Substance Abuse—PG; Adult Themes—PG
for eating disorders
Robin’s Comments:
Though it doesn’t live up to the hype, it is serviceable for
readers, primarily girls, who like to read sad books. For a better treatment of imaginary worlds
and a WAY better story, recommend A Great
and Terrible Beauty by Libba Bray.
Monday, December 15, 2014
THE YOUNG ELITES, by Marie Lu
The story: Blood fever has swept through the land of Kenettra, killing it adult victims, and scarring the children "lucky" enough to live. Ever more frightening are the dark powers possessed by some of the survivors: the Young Elites, marked by disease and gifted with strange and remarkable abilities. Now the government has sworn to rid the country of these powerful, shadowy figures--just as the hideously-scarred Adelina comes to recognize that she possesses powers which can either get her killed...or allow her to do the killing.
June Cleaver's ratings: Language G; Violence R; Sexual content PG-13; Nudity PG; substance abuse PG; magic & the occult R; GLBT content PG; adult themes (murder committed by teens; abusive relationships; exceptionally dark subject matter) R; overall rating R.
Liz's comments: This story, obviously a series opener, is quite different from the "Legend" series in that it's fantasy rather than dystopian and the main character has magical rather than technological or intellectual powers. Lu is a skillful world builder, but the story is so dark and violent, and the heroine driven so much by rage and hate, that it became kind of a slog to get done with it. There's not a single moment of comic relief--in fact, everything that happens is so dark that it seems like the whole story takes place at night. This one, even though there's not a single "F" word in it, is going up to the high school: too many murders committed by teens (wronged or not), too much violence, too much ugliness. It should have been rated 9th-up by one and all.
June Cleaver's ratings: Language G; Violence R; Sexual content PG-13; Nudity PG; substance abuse PG; magic & the occult R; GLBT content PG; adult themes (murder committed by teens; abusive relationships; exceptionally dark subject matter) R; overall rating R.
Liz's comments: This story, obviously a series opener, is quite different from the "Legend" series in that it's fantasy rather than dystopian and the main character has magical rather than technological or intellectual powers. Lu is a skillful world builder, but the story is so dark and violent, and the heroine driven so much by rage and hate, that it became kind of a slog to get done with it. There's not a single moment of comic relief--in fact, everything that happens is so dark that it seems like the whole story takes place at night. This one, even though there's not a single "F" word in it, is going up to the high school: too many murders committed by teens (wronged or not), too much violence, too much ugliness. It should have been rated 9th-up by one and all.
Wednesday, December 10, 2014
ATLANTIA, by Ally Condie
The story: After the Divide, humans live both below and above the sea. Rio lives Below, where she hides a deadly secret: she is a Siren, someone who can use her voice to influence other people's actions--even against their wills. Devastated when her twin sister chooses to live Above, Rio begins to question their mother's death, her city's government, and the circumstances that will force her to spend the rest of her life Below. And the more she finds out...the more dangerous her life becomes. Will the truth ultimately kill her?
June Cleaver's ratings: Language G; Violence PG-13; Sexual content PG; Nudity G; magic and the occult PG; substance abuse PG; adult themes PG (death of a parent, political conspiracies) PG; overall rating PG (although I would recommend it for older readers; it requires a little too much thinking for the average 6th grader).
Liz's comments: I really liked this one, and was surprised when it resolved neatly at the end--a stand-alone book, and not the first in a trilogy. I even felt a little bit sad about that (although in general, I find the trend for everything to be a trilogy just a little irksome)! Condie's writing is strong, and her world-building is interesting and thought-provoking.
Tuesday, December 9, 2014
The Good Girls Revolt
In 1970, a group of women, mostly employed as researchers
and fact checkers at Newsweek magazine, filed a lawsuit against the publication
for gender discrimination on the same day Newsweek ran a cover story entitled, “Women
in Revolt.” The Good Girls Revolt tells
the story of the brave women who risked their futures to make the workplace fairer. The Newsweek suit was the first class-action
suit brought by women, it was also the first by women journalists; the Newsweek suit would be followed by others
at Time, The New York Times, and Reader’s Digest.
Results were good for some of the women, and less so for
others, but many of them recall this as a defining moment in their lives. They stood up for themselves and the fact
that they were being institutionally discriminated against because they were
women. They had the same Ivy League
educations and the same writing credentials as the men, and yet they were never
going to advance beyond researcher at Newsweek.
In some cases they were told this in no uncertain terms. Often, women of the sixties accepted this
type of treatment as “just the way things were.” But after the civil rights act was passed
including a provision which outlawed sex discrimination, Judy Gingold started
attending a conscientious raising group, where she had an “aha” moment that
would make all the difference.
These were not angry, man-hating, bra-burning,
feminists. They were nice girls who had
labored under the illusion that hard work and achievement would get them where
they wanted to go. Once they realized
those things would never be enough, they decided to do something to change the
system.
I wish every woman under thirty would read this book for
two big reasons. First, they would
realize the debt they owe to the women who came before them. Sometimes, it is tempting to think that the
way things are is the way they have always been. Reading about the real women who put their
real reputations on the line to help others might give a little perspective to
modern young women. Second, young women
might be less inclined towards apathy.
Women have yet to attain real equality.
It is true that great strides have been made, but as long as women are
undervalued and over-sexualized, there is no equality.
An excellent choice for those interested in civil rights, history, or women's issues.
Thursday, December 4, 2014
THE IRON TRIAL (Magisterium #1) by Holly Black and Cassandra Clare
The story: When most kids hear "magical", they think of something special. Not Callum Hunt--he thinks of the power that killed his mother, and that's now taking him away from his dad. He tries his hardest to flunk the magical test waiting for him at the Magisterium, but he can't do it. There's a power deep inside him waiting to come out--but is it for good, or for evil?
June Cleaver's ratings: Language PG; Violence PG; sexual content G; nudity G; magical and the occult PG-13; substance abuse PG; adult themes (death of a parent; betrayal) PG; overall rating PG.
Liz's comments: As a fantasy fan, I enjoyed this story, but it does occur to me that that yet another kid sent to a magical school to discover powers about which he knows nothing is not exactly new territory. However, the Magisterium is a cool underground world, Callum doesn't know who he can trust, and isn't even sure whether he'll turn out to be the good guy in his own story. What's a boy to do--except maybe shoot some fire bolts, steal a lizard, and make sure not to say anything to any adult who might be able to keep him from doing something crazy?
THE FAMILY ROMANOV, by Candace Fleming
The story: This is the true story of the fate of the last Tsar of Russia and the terrible times in which he lived: times when peasants, oppressed by the rich and driven to desperation by starvation and ill use, turned their society upside down and literally destroyed it.
June Cleaver's ratings: Language G; Violence PG-13; Sexual Content G; Nudity G; Substance abuse PG; magic and the occult PG; adult themes (oppressive societies & their behaviors) PG; Overall rating PG.
Liz's comments: Despite its PG rating, this is not a book for middle-school students. Its well-written prose is very fact-heavy, and Fleming spends a good deal of necessary time setting up the political background of Russia and its Tsar at the turn of the 20th century. All but the most historically-interested MS kids will have bailed by page 20 (the book is reviewed for high school for this reason). I found it very interesting, but not exactly fast moving.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




